Oh, I'm scared if I look in your eyes
I might see your soul
I know love is the loneliest place
When you fall alone

Sitting by the phone, holding onto hope
Spending all night wondering why you let me go (you let me go)
I wish you would feel how you're feeling two years ago
Oh, nah

Hurts me to hurt you, baby
Lying awake and everything has changed
Keeping our distance lately
Kills me to kill you when I tell you
That I felt it once, I can't feel it twice
It's more than I can take, baby
Hurts me to tell you I don't feel the same

I can feel you still staring at me
When I look away
Can't imagine the pain that you feel
When I kiss his face

That's when you said
How can I be your friend when I know the way you taste?
It's almost 2 am and I can't ask you to stay
I don't know what's worse: Getting broken or making it break
Oh, ah

Hurts me to hurt you, baby
Lying awake and everything has changed
Keeping our distance lately
Kills me to kill you when I tell you
That I felt it once, I can't feel it twice
It's more than I can take, baby
Hurts me to tell you I don't feel the same

Hurts me to hurt you, baby
Feels like there's nothing that I can say
Hurts me to hurt you, baby
Kills me, I have to walk away
'Cause I felt it once, I can't feel it twice
It's more than I can take, baby
Hurts me to tell you I don't feel the same

The same, oh, yeah, the same
Oh, the same, oh, yeah
Oh, yeah, the same
Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh
Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh